Companies We Represent

With us, you have options.

Here are the insurance companies we currently work with. Already a customer? Feel free to use the provided links or phone numbers to manage your account.

Aetna

Aetna

Manage Account Online

Phone: Requires Member Login.

AFLAC

AFLAC

Manage Account Online

Phone: 877-442-3522

Anthem Blue Cross

Anthem Blue Cross

Manage Account Online

Phone: Please call the Member Service number on the back of your Member ID Card.

Church Underwriters, Inc.

Church Underwriters, Inc.

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-869-8904

ERIE Insurance Group

ERIE Insurance Group

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-642-1948

Foremost

Foremost

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-527-3905

Golden Rule/United

Golden Rule/United

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-657-8205

Grange

Grange

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-445-3030

Hagerty

Hagerty

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-922-4050

Humana

Humana

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-457-4708

J.C. Taylor

J.C. Taylor

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-345-8290

Mapfre

Mapfre

Manage Account Online

Phone: 855-627-3732

Medical Mutual Of Ohio

Medical Mutual Of Ohio

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-722-7331

Merchants Bonding Company

Merchants Bonding Company

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-678-8171

National Flood Insurance Program

National Flood Insurance Program

Manage Account Online

Phone: 888-379-9531

Ohio Fair Plan

Ohio Fair Plan

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-282-1772

Ohio Mutual Insurance Co.

Ohio Mutual Insurance Co.

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-686-3011

Peerless Insurance

Peerless Insurance

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-522-7152

Philadelphia Insurance Companies

Philadelphia Insurance Companies

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-765-9749

Progressive

Progressive

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-776-4737

Safeco Insurance Co. of America

Safeco Insurance Co. of America

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-332-3226

UnitedHealthcare

UnitedHealthcare

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-357-0978

Wayne Mutual Insurance Company

Wayne Mutual Insurance Company

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-222-3873 x310

Western Reserve Group

Western Reserve Group

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-362-0426


Need an insurance quote? Get in touch!

Access quotes from Ohio's most trusted insurance carriers. It’s comparison shopping at the click of a mouse.